A simple change to the sutherland shire council logo has become a national argument about Captain James Cook. For designers, the lesson is less comfortable: a mark that once passed unnoticed can now carry political weight.
Sutherland Shire sits in Sydney’s south and has a population of around 240,000. It rarely attracts national press attention. That changed in recent weeks, when the council’s crest drew scrutiny. The crest carries an engraved portrait of Captain James Cook, who first came ashore on Australia‘s east coast at Kurnell, within the shire, in 1770.
In July, staff began favouring a newer, simpler sutherland shire council logo across council communications. It is a light blue wave that represents the area’s place on Australia’s east coast.

What the council actually changed
Cook has not been cancelled, removed or erased. The council moved the crest to what it calls “civic, ceremonial and high-value corporate applications.” The wave now handles jobs such as email signatures, where a simpler mark works better.
Councillor Haris Strangas says nobody asked him about the sutherland shire council logo change. He tabled a motion to review the council’s policy. He then appeared on the Today show, a major national breakfast TV programme, to explain his position.
He is, in the clip, a likeable and ordinary figure. He said he did not want to inflame the issue, and he acknowledged most people have better things to talk about. He did not back down, though. Sutherland Shire became a front in Australia’s long-running culture wars, and other people quickly added their own agendas.

Why logos change, even the sutherland shire council logo
Logos are tools, not monuments. Organisations tweak, update or replace them when they look tired or stop working, such as on small screens. Doing so is maintenance, not vandalism.
Mastercard dropped its name from its circles emblem in 2019. Volkswagen flattened its badge the same year. Burger King returned to its retro bun in 2021, and Pepsi brought back a bolder, blacker globe in 2023. Each change is a reminder that redesigns usually succeed without a public fight. For more on the people behind famous marks, see The 50 Greatest Designers.
Cook imagery on the sutherland shire council logo has changed before. In 2008, the council shrank Cook in favour of its name and a new colour scheme. Ahead of the 250th anniversary of Cook’s landing, it restyled the portrait for digital screens. The wave itself arrived as the new council logo in 2017. None of those changes made national news.
What this means for designers
A rebrand is no longer just a rebrand. Once people treat a symbol as a stand-in for something larger, every design decision becomes a statement. The conversation moves away from colour, type and kerning and toward identity.
History matters, and communities should have a say in how they are represented. The council’s decision, however, changed a sutherland shire council logo design for specific uses. It did not erase a historical figure. Keeping that distinction clear is part of the designer’s job now.
The backlash puts designers in a bind. Clients may take the lesson from examples such as Cracker Barrel and Jaguar that it is safer never to change anything. That is poor for design and worse for organisations, which end up stuck with identities that no longer work. For a broader look at how creative ideas get argued, Great TED Talks: Creativity is a useful starting point.
The Sutherland Shire row began with a wave. If it teaches clients to freeze every mark in place, designers will lose the chance to make organisations’ identities work for the people they serve.

Via creativebloq.com
Frequently asked questions
What did Sutherland Shire Council actually change about its logo?
The council moved its crest, which carries an engraved portrait of Captain James Cook, to civic, ceremonial and high-value corporate uses. A simpler light blue wave now handles everyday jobs such as email signatures, and Cook has not been cancelled, removed or erased.
Why does the Sutherland Shire Council logo feature Captain James Cook?
The crest carries an engraved portrait of Captain James Cook, who first came ashore on Australia’s east coast at Kurnell, within the shire, in 1770. The article does not give further reasons for the choice.
Has the Sutherland Shire Council logo changed before?
Yes, in 2008 the council shrank the Cook imagery in favour of its name and a new colour scheme. Ahead of the 250th anniversary of Cook’s landing, it restyled the portrait for digital screens, and the wave arrived as the new council logo in 2017.
Who is Councillor Haris Strangas and what has he done about the logo?
Councillor Haris Strangas tabled a motion to review the council’s policy on the logo change. He then appeared on the Today show to explain his position, saying he did not want to inflame the issue but did not back down.
More in
Graphic Design
All Graphic Design



More like this

Caixa's New Logo Turns Its X Into a Savings Box and House Roof

Cracker Barrel's Controversial Logo Shift: How a Rebrand Sparked a Leadership Overhaul

Bloomington's New Logo Controversy: A Design Debate with Local Impact
Fast Food Icons and Tech Giants Playfully React to Instagram's Logo Transformation
