Flemington Estate's high-rise public housing towers in Melbourne, part of the wider debate over melbourne public housing towers.

Architect Concedes Some Melbourne Towers Are Beyond Repair but Urges Refurbishment Studies

User avatar placeholder
Written by Seth Sebastian

2026-11-19

The state is scheduled to demolish 44 melbourne public housing towers, but architect Simon Robinson and his team at Office say the buildings can be saved, and they have produced studies to show it.

Robinson leads calls for the Victorian government to reconsider its plan. He and his colleagues argue that retrofitting the estates is the smarter option.

A plan to raze and rebuild melbourne public housing towers

In 2023, the Labor state government announced the High-Rise Redevelopment Program (HRRP). Homes Victoria, the state housing body, will demolish all 44 towers and many lower-rise blocks, replacing them with new housing by 2051.

Simon Robinson, director of Office, pictured in the centre of the group.
Simon Robinson (centre) is the director of Office

Officials argue that the melbourne public housing towers, built between 1962 and 1975, have reached the end of their useful lives. They say the buildings fall short of modern standards and cost too much to maintain. The program, they claim, will triple housing capacity and raise the quality of homes.

The plan has drawn fierce opposition over its lack of transparency and its consultation with the residents being moved out. It is now the subject of an ongoing legal dispute. It has also prompted concern from the UN’s special rapporteur on housing, and it has become a political issue ahead of the Victorian state election.

Studies the government has not published

Office is a Melbourne not-for-profit research and design practice. It began working pro bono after residents told the team that the government had not published any feasibility study for keeping the condemned estates.

Flemington Estate remains standing, not yet demolished, as residents' class action continues.
Flemington Estate has not yet been demolished while a class file action filed by the residents is in progress

“We thought that was pretty odd that you wouldn’t do a refurbishment study on these estates,” Office director Simon Robinson told Dezeen. “So we took it upon ourselves to start to do these feasibility studies, along with public housing residents.”

The government did carry out feasibility work on public housing refurbishment, according to Robinson. It has kept those studies out of public view, even after the Victorian Legislative Council requested them.

“We’re not saying that they’re in perfect condition,” he said. “We’re also not saying that all of them should be refurbished. Perhaps some are beyond repair. All we are saying is that these refurbishment studies need to occur.”

The cost of moving people

Office estimates that a retrofit and infill approach would cost about $300 million less than demolition and rebuilding. The saving comes from keeping residents in their homes, so no one needs to be moved.

Robinson says the government leaves out the cost of rehousing people during construction. “As all the estates are occupied, the cost of relocating and housing the residents during construction work needs to be included in the project cost,” he said. “This is consistently excluded and never disclosed.”

He adds that reports suggest the government buys or head-leases homes on the private market to house displaced tenants. “We have estimated that these costs are very significant,” Robinson said.

Retain, repair, reinvest

Office’s counter-proposal rests on a strategy it calls Retain Repair Reinvest (RRR). The approach keeps buildings standing and lets residents stay put while renovations improve comfort and energy efficiency. It also cuts construction waste and carbon emissions.

Flemington Estate housing towers, where a renovation proposal claims savings of around $300 million.
Office’s says its proposal to renovate the Flemington Estate would save around $300 million

Reuse can give tired buildings a second life, as this Atlanta warehouse conversion shows: Atlanta’s Historic Warehouse Turned Vibrant Art Hub is a useful comparison for retrofit debates.

Robinson accepts that most of Victoria’s public housing, including the melbourne public housing towers, is in poor shape. Buildings are run-down, cold in winter and stifling in summer. He argues that renovation can still deliver comfortable living conditions.

To test the strategy, Office built hypothetical case studies for three Melbourne estates: Ascot Vale Estate, Barak Beacon Estate and Flemington Estate.

Flemington shows the stakes most clearly. The estate once housed roughly 1,500 people across four of the melbourne public housing towers, which together make up about a tenth of Victoria’s high-rise public housing. Only about 32 households remain. An injunction stops Homes Victoria from issuing further eviction notices while legal challenges continue.

Office’s scheme would keep all 720 existing homes at Flemington. Between them, the team would add 577 infill social units, which raises the density of the site.

The plan includes new facades and private balconies. It also proposes underground parking, a shared green space at the centre of the estate, new heating and cooling, better insulation, and updated kitchens and bathrooms.

Office says the package would cut global warming potential by 55 percent compared with demolition. Double glazing, photovoltaic panels and water conservation systems are part of that package.

Audience gathered for a public talk and exhibition about Melbourne housing estates.
Office will focus on doing more public talks and exhibitions to raise awareness of the issue

The state government has so far shown little interest in the studies. Robinson thinks the reason is simple. The government does not want to run public housing itself.

“When the state government manages public housing, they are responsible for maintaining the buildings and organising new tenants – all the admin that comes with owning a building,” he said.

The type of housing planned under HRRP is also drawing scrutiny. The new homes will be community housing, not like-for-like public housing. Private developers will build them, and they will be split between below-market and market-rate rentals.

The state still classes community housing as social housing. It costs slightly more to rent, though, and tenants have less security against eviction.

Robinson believes the label was chosen to mislead. “What they’re building is community housing, not public housing, so there’s no longer any public housing being rebuilt in Victoria,” he said.

“The government is now calling everything social housing, because they don’t want the public to know that it’s no longer public housing,” he added. “Victoria has the lowest percentage of public housing stock in Australia, and we’re currently demolishing it all and turning it into private and community housing.”

Shelter as infrastructure

The debate over melbourne public housing towers takes place against a severe affordability crisis. More than 60,000 people are on the social housing waitlist in Victoria. Social housing makes up 3 percent of the state’s dwellings, against a national average of 4.2 percent and an OECD average of 7 percent.

“Public housing serves as foundational social infrastructure that treats shelter as an essential human right,” Robinson said. “By offering rents permanently capped to income and delivering unmatched security of tenure, it provides an unconditional safety net for society’s most vulnerable households.”

Office’s work has reached Parliament. In November 2023, the Victorian Legislative Council debated the merits of the RRR approach. The council’s Legal and Social Issues Committee was urging the government to reconsider demolition and to explore every refurbishment option.

The team has already won one small victory. Ascot Vale Estate was the first RRR case study Office released. Homes Victoria quietly removed the estate from its planned demolitions list, and part of the estate has since been refurbished.

Dating from 1947, the estate’s brick buildings rise only three storeys. Modernist architect and public housing advocate Best Overend designed them while working for the Housing Commission. The estate contains 57 blocks.

That outcome gave Robinson’s team hope. “We have presented to Homes Victoria, we’ve presented to different ministers as well, and we’ve kind of heard that they are starting to look at retrofit some of their existing building stock,” he said.

“It kind of suggests that perhaps they’re gonna prefer we show all of them. So we released the following studies on Barak Beacon Estate and the Flemington Estate.”

The hope has limits. Barak Beacon Estate has already been demolished, and the replacement buildings are due for completion by the end of the year. Flemington’s future now depends on a High Court of Australia ruling, which will follow a hearing held last month.

A class action brought by Inner Melbourne Community Legal, on behalf of public housing residents in North Melbourne and Flemington, is at its final appeal. The Supreme Court of Victoria and the Victorian Court of Appeal both ruled in favour of demolition.

Ascot Valley Estate, removed from the demolition list and since refurbished.
Ascot Valley Estate was removed from the demolition list by the government and has since been refurbished

The Liberal opposition has pledged to pause HRRP if it wins office at the upcoming election.

Barak Beacon Estate site after demolition, with redevelopment set to finish by year's end.
Barak Beacon Estate was demolished, the redevelopment is set to finish by the end of the year

Robinson says his team has reached the limit of what reports can do. “We’ve gotten to a point where we feel we can’t just keep putting out these reports,” he said.

The studies are dense and aimed at specialists, so Office is turning them into a series of publications for bookshops and general readers. The team also gives interviews, speaks with residents, advocates and professionals, and delivers lectures.

Robinson also wants the architecture profession to take a harder look at the estate renewals. Many of Australia’s best-known studios are working on them, and some projects have won awards as exemplars of public good.

Melbourne’s architecture scene offers more than estate politics, and Casa Piva’s Seclusion and Elegance in Malvern East shows the city’s quieter, private side.

“All the big-name architects are working on these estate renewals, some have even won awards as exemplar projects for these architects to promote their practice in terms of doing public good,” he said. “It’s really hard to find anyone who’s willing to talk about why they’re doing it, or is it good, the displacement and environmental issues. We’re alone.”

Dezeen asked the Victorian government to respond to Robinson’s claims. It declined to comment in the lead-up to the election.

Flemington Estate's high-rise public housing towers in Melbourne, part of the wider debate over melbourne public housing towers.
Flemington Estate in Melbourne

Via dezeen.com

Frequently asked questions

What is the High-Rise Redevelopment Program for Melbourne public housing towers?

The High-Rise Redevelopment Program (HRRP) was announced in 2023 by the Labor state government. Homes Victoria will demolish all 44 towers and many lower-rise blocks, replacing them with new housing by 2051.

How much could retrofitting Melbourne public housing save compared to demolition?

Office estimates that a retrofit and infill approach would cost about $300 million less than demolishing and rebuilding. The saving comes from keeping residents in their homes, so no one needs to be moved.

How many homes would Office’s plan keep at Flemington Estate?

Office’s scheme would keep all 720 existing homes at Flemington Estate. The team would also add 577 infill social units to the site.

Why did Office start its own feasibility studies on the estates?

Office began working pro bono after residents told the team that the government had not published any feasibility study for keeping the condemned estates. Its director, Simon Robinson, said it seemed odd that no refurbishment study had been done.

Menu