A barricade blocks a public staircase at the Shanghai Opera House, cutting off a route visitors once used freely.

Snøhetta’s Shanghai Opera House Stair Fee Sparks Online Anger Over Public Access

User avatar placeholder
Written by Seth Sebastian

2026-11-21

Visitors pay 50 RMB, about eight US dollars, to climb the cantilevered stair at the new Shanghai Opera House. The fee has sparked complaints online. It also raises a basic design question about who gets access to buildings meant to be walked over.

Public staircase at a Snøhetta-designed opera house, central to the online dispute over access fees.
Photo by Kaia Wang

Buildings as hills

Aaron Betsky, a senior design associate at Carlo Ratti Associati and former president of the School of Architecture at Taliesin, argues that architects need to be realistic about how buildings operate. Many recent Chinese projects behave less like buildings and more like landscapes. People walk up them, around them, through them, and over them.

Ma Yansong‘s firm, MAD Architects, often builds hills to be climbed. The Shenzhen Bay Cultural Center is one example. The Quzhou Sports Center is made of five separate hills that visitors can scale. The Harbin Opera House, completed in 2015, includes a route across the top of its auditorium.

The Kowloon High Speed Train Station, designed by Andrew Bromberg of Aedas, takes a different approach. Its roof forms one continuous curve. Visitors can climb it and look across the harbor toward Hong Kong Island.

Snøhetta‘s recently completed Shanghai Opera House adds a cantilevered stair. At the top, visitors get a view back across the river to the city.

For a sense of how other Shanghai projects handle public-facing form, see this look at Shanghai’s helical roof reshaping the city skyline, which shows how a rooftop can become a civic landmark.

Where the barriers appear

Public access rarely stays open for long. Sooner or later, visitors reach a barrier. It is usually a temporary one, made from movable fences and lots of yellow and black tape.

Many of these limits are about money. Owners who spent extra on a striking roof or terrace often find that crowds of selfie takers arrive soon after. Some then turn the view into a revenue source. The Shanghai Opera House is the latest example, and the 50 RMB stair fee shows how quickly that can happen.

Online reaction has been harsher to the fee than to earlier closures. Commenters argue that a photo against a city skyline should be a public right. Betsky points out that the building was largely paid for with state funds, which complicates that argument.

The pattern is not limited to China. Across the world, buildings designed to be explored in three dimensions face rules that limit movement. Safety and security concerns often override the open, continuous flow that architects draw.

In Europe, the limits look more like airport security routes. Visitors can reach the top of MVRDV’s Depot in Rotterdam or Herzog & de Meuron’s Elbphilharmonie in Hamburg without paying. They must work out the route on their own, and the path usually passes a café or bar.

Betsky sees this as a normal trade in an economy that sells experiences. Space and views count among the most valuable luxuries available. He says he does not see the problem as serious, at least until a different economic model replaces the current one.

The fences are the real problem

The barriers themselves may cause the most damage. Even visitors willing to pay in Shanghai find that the fences block more than access. They also obscure the views and the architecture the visitor came to see.

The fences stand out because architects never designed them in. Signs, furnishings, and security devices clutter many buildings, especially in China and increasingly elsewhere. Those added after construction draw the most attention.

Theo Deutinger, an architect, catalogued this clutter in his book Handbook of Tyranny. The book diagrams many devices that control how people move through buildings. Most go unnoticed. A camera hidden in a ceiling is easy to ignore, but a fence across a stair is not.

China has added these controls only recently, which makes them more visible. The Harbin Opera House, opened in 2015, once let people clamber across its surfaces freely. The same was true of the Kowloon station shortly after it opened. Today, both sites have far more restrictions.

Local officials now worry about the same liability issues that have shaped Western buildings for decades. Chinese law makes it hard to sue over a fall on a public site. Officials, however, can face penalties from the government if an accident happens on a building they oversee. Architects in China told Betsky that such penalties are becoming more common.

Not every change is a loss. Ramps and other access features have improved entry for people with mobility limits, toddlers, and older visitors. These groups often gain the most from urban landscapes. Steven Holl’s Brooklyn Library shows the opposite risk: layered, complicated design can exclude large groups of users.

Designers can avoid that trade-off by planning access and safety together from the start. The Lucas Museum of Narrative Art in Los Angeles, designed by Ma Yansong, does this with its surrounding park. The landscape was designed by Mia Lehrer, founder and president of Studio-MLA. The museum opens in September 2026.

People can be guided up and over buildings without being locked out. Charging for the view is a business choice. Designing a route that works for everyone is the harder task.

The promise of open space

Zaha Hadid’s folds and curves pointed toward a different future. Her buildings were meant to let city life drift freely into sheltered and climate-controlled rooms, with no gates or checkpoints in between.

Blobitecture and parametricism promised the same openness. Wolf Prix, a founder of Coop Himmelb(l)au, has called for an “open architecture of the open eye, the open mind, the open heart” for decades.

Physics and budgets set limits on those ideas. A curved shell still needs a door, a staircase, and space for plumbing. Developers and owners pay for the result, and they set the terms of access.

Rem Koolhaas put it bluntly: “all conditioned space is conditional.” The same logic now applies outdoors. Access to a rooftop or a hill depends on a ticket, a permit, or a rule posted at the gate.

Mountable architecture has spread quickly over the past few decades, and at larger scales each time. These projects promise a more open society. So far, they have delivered more promise than utopia. Visitors can climb nearly any building, but economics and regulation will eventually bring them back down.

A barricade blocks a public staircase at the Shanghai Opera House, cutting off a route visitors once used freely.
Shanghai Grand Opera House public staircase barricade

H/T dezeen.com

Frequently asked questions

How much does it cost to climb the Shanghai Opera House stair?

Visitors pay 50 RMB, about eight US dollars, to climb the cantilevered stair at the new Shanghai Opera House. The fee has drawn complaints online.

Why are people angry about the Shanghai Opera House stair fee?

Commenters argue that a photo against a city skyline should be a public right, and online reaction has been harsher to this fee than to earlier closures. Betsky notes that the building was largely paid for with state funds, which complicates that argument.

Why do fences and barriers appear at public building viewpoints?

Many barriers are about money, because owners who spend extra on a striking roof or terrace often find crowds of selfie takers arrive soon after. Some owners then turn the view into a revenue source, as the Shanghai Opera House stair fee shows.

Have the Harbin Opera House and Kowloon station restricted visitors?

Yes. The Harbin Opera House once let people clamber across its surfaces freely, and the Kowloon station was similar shortly after it opened. Today, both sites have far more restrictions.

Menu