Three photographers say the pictures they took at a St. Paul protest now serve as the strongest evidence of what happened to them. Aaron Nesheim, Kerem Yücel and Timothy Evans have sued the St. Paul Police Department in Minnesota, alleging officers hit them with chemical munitions while they worked.

The lawsuit was filed on Tuesday. Some of the photos in this story show people in visible distress.
A raid, a crowd and a press line
The case began on November 25, when U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents tried to arrest a man at his home in St. Paul’s Payne-Phalen neighborhood. A crowd of protesters gathered outside the house as federal agents worked to detain him.
Nesheim, a photographer for Sahan Journal, and Yücel, a photojournalist for MPR News, arrived to document the demonstration. Evans, a freelancer, came too. Each carried a large professional camera and wore a press pass. Evans also wore a ballistic vest marked “PRESS.”
Documentary photographers often become the record of events like this, and Brian Condron’s Leica photos of 1970s Toronto show how a camera can preserve a city in transition.


Tear gas as officers pulled back
The federal agents left with the detained man. Protesters then told the St. Paul police to leave as well. According to a report by the Minnesota Reformer, officers fired pepper balls and used pepper spray and tear gas as they withdrew, hitting protesters and journalists alike.


Paul police target the photographers
According to court documents, an officer pepper-sprayed Yücel at close range while he photographed the scene. The complaint says he inhaled and swallowed the chemicals. Other officers struck him with pepper balls in the neck, shoulders and chest.
The complaint also states that the three photographers stood together at the edge of the crowd. They were at least 10 feet from the nearest protester and clear of officers. Paul police allegedly fired pepper balls and launched police tear gas at them anyway.
All three reported irritation to their eyes and airways. Yücel struggled to breathe and was taken from the scene by ambulance. According to MPR News, he had to place his jacket in a garbage bag to keep the chemicals away from others. Regions Hospital then said it could not admit him to the main hospital, because the irritants on his body and clothing posed a safety risk to staff and other patients.
Evans suffered severe abdominal bruising after a pepper ball burst inside his ballistic vest. A police projectile struck Nesheim in the head. All three needed mental health treatment after the incident.

What the lawsuit demands
The photographers argue the department violated their rights under the First, Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments to the U.S. Constitution. They also allege assault and battery, among other violations. They seek damages, attorney’s fees and a court order barring the department from further unconstitutional conduct against them.
Photographs can also challenge official narratives about who gets seen, as McClellan’s Photos Showing Black Rodeo Life does by replacing a familiar stereotype with everyday community portraits.
Attorney Kevin Riach argues the force was aimed at the press. “The use of this tear gas, like the use of the pepper balls, was clearly meant as retaliation for plaintiffs’ exercise of their First Amendment rights,” Riach writes. “The officers could not have been shooting at anyone other than Nesheim, Yücel and Evans, who were all clustered within several feet of one another.”
The photographers took these pictures to document a protest. Now the same images may show a court what happened to the people holding the cameras.

H/T petapixel.com
Frequently asked questions
Who filed the lawsuit against the St. Paul Police Department?
Three photographers, Aaron Nesheim, Kerem Yücel, and Timothy Evans, filed the lawsuit. They allege that St. Paul police officers hit them with chemical munitions while they were working at a protest.
What led to police using tear gas at the St. Paul protest?
The protest began on November 25, when U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents tried to arrest a man at his home in St. Paul’s Payne-Phalen neighborhood. After the federal agents left with the man, protesters told the police to leave, and officers fired pepper balls and used pepper spray and tear gas as they withdrew.
What constitutional rights do the photographers claim police violated?
The photographers argue the police department violated their rights under the First, Fourth, and Fourteenth Amendments to the U.S. Constitution. They also allege assault and battery, among other violations, and seek damages, attorney’s fees, and a court order barring further unconstitutional conduct.
What injuries did photographer Kerem Yücel suffer during the protest?
According to the complaint, an officer pepper-sprayed Yücel at close range, and he inhaled and swallowed the chemicals. Other officers struck him with pepper balls in the neck, shoulders, and chest, and he was taken from the scene by ambulance.
More in
Photography
All Photography




