Renovated Cherry Lane Theatre by A24 and Leroy Street Studio on historic cherry lane, blending modern with classic.

Historic Cherry Lane Theatre Transformed: A24 and Leroy Street Studio’s Modern Revival

User avatar placeholder
Written by John Oliver

2026-08-30

A Timeless Venue Revamped for a New Era

In a significant move, production company A24 partnered with Leroy Street Studio to breathe new life into New York City‘s oldest Off-Broadway theatre, the historic Cherry Lane Theatre. Acquired by A24 in 2023, the theatre plans to retain its celebrated name while enhancing its capabilities for hosting live productions and film screenings.

Leroy Street Studio design-build project of Cherry Lane Theatre interior renovation.
Leroy Street Studio acted as a design-build studio for the renovation of Cherry Lane Theatre

Preserving the Past While Embracing the Future

The renovation project included the addition of Wild Cherry, a speakeasy-style restaurant by the creators of the popular Frenchette bistro. The theatre, nestled between two historic brick buildings on Commerce Street in the West Village, dates back to the 1830s. Originally a manufacturing site and later a grain silo, it became a theatre in 1924, making it a cornerstone of Cherry Lane.

Main stage of theatre with giant screening rig descending from ceiling.
The main stage converts into a small movie theatre via a giant screening rig that descends from the ceiling

Leroy Street Studio focused on peeling back layers of previous renovations to honor the building’s history, including restoring the bright red doors with the original painter. “We wanted to celebrate some of the original features,” said LSS senior interiors associate Leslie Bailey. “Peeling back was a significant part of our work,” added LSS senior associate Alex Witko.

Theatre ticket booth covered in deep blue tile adornment.
The ticket booth is clad in a deep blue tile

Innovative Design for Modern Needs

One of the major renovations involved transforming the original main stage into a dual-purpose venue. Equipped with a descending screening rig and speakers, the space now accommodates both live performances and film. The seating was replaced with luxurious mossy green banquettes, and adjustments were made to suit different audio demands. The theatre now stands as an emblem of modern adaptability while respecting its storied past.

Enhance your understanding of innovative design through this exhibit amid opulent surroundings that explores the intersection of art and architecture.

Lobby area featuring extensive use of deep blue tile throughout.
The same blue tile runs into the lobby

The venue can seamlessly switch between film and live programming, with curtains used to adjust acoustics, allowing rapid conversion within a day.

For another project featuring both past and future elements, discover unexpected softness captured through lenses at Montana’s Oldest Rodeo.

Concealed restaurant interior hidden behind large hanging curtain.
A restaurant is concealed behind a curtain

Welcoming Space for Creativity and Cuisine

The updated building features a flowing box office that leads to a lobby with ocean blue tile, exposed brick walls, restrooms, and entrance to Wild Cherry hidden by a rich red curtain. The restaurant boasts a textured design with a scalloped ceiling, adeptly crafted to prevent sound from disturbing the residential units above. This addition further enriches the appeal of the venue.

Wild Cherry speakeasy with a richly textured interior atmosphere.
The speakeasy-like Wild Cherry contains “texture upon texture”

“Creating a series of boxes within boxes helped successfully separate the restaurant sound from the residential floors,” explained Witko.

A Landmark Reimagined

Cherry Lane Theatre, now complemented by the vibrant Wild Cherry, began rolling out performances and screenings, such as the play Weer. This project marks A24’s debut in establishing a physical venue, reflecting a broader trend of media companies, like Amazon, investing in live-performance spaces. Situated on this historic street, the theatre continues to be a vital part of the cultural landscape.

Leroy Street Studio’s previous achievements include designing a Hamptons home and curating an exhibition during New York design week. The meticulous photography of this rejuvenated theatre is by Brian Ferry.

Source: dezeen.com

Frequently asked questions

What renovations were made to Cherry Lane Theatre?

The renovations included transforming the original main stage into a dual-purpose venue for live performances and film screenings, replacing seating with luxurious mossy green banquettes, and adding Wild Cherry, a speakeasy-style restaurant. Layers of previous renovations were peeled back to honor the building’s history, including restoring the bright red doors.

Who partnered to revamp Cherry Lane Theatre?

Production company A24 partnered with Leroy Street Studio to revamp Cherry Lane Theatre, breathing new life into New York City’s oldest Off-Broadway theatre.

What is the purpose of the Wild Cherry addition?

Wild Cherry is a speakeasy-style restaurant added to the theatre, designed to enrich the venue’s appeal. It features a scalloped ceiling to prevent sound from disturbing the residential units above.