Hillside home in Montauk with stone walls and ocean views, blending historic and modern styles.

Modern Montauk Home Melds Historic Forms with Expansive Views and Contemporary Comfort

User avatar placeholder
Written by Seth Sebastian

2026-07-13

Embracing Montauk’s Heritage in a Modern Design

High on a hill in Montauk, New York, Bates Masi + Architects have created a striking family home that nods to the area’s agricultural history while embracing contemporary living. The site itself is steeped in history, once belonging to some of Montauk’s earliest settlers, with remnants of horse stables and workers’ cottages still visible in the landscape.

A mid-20th-century cottage once occupied one of the site’s most enviable spots, offering panoramic views of the lake, ocean, sound, and nearby nature preserves. The new homeowners wanted to maintain the modest look of this cottage and the open landscape while expanding the space to comfortably host a family of five year-round.

Montauk hillside home by Bates Masi + Architects showcasing stone and glass elements.
This hillside home in Montauk, New York, by Bates Masi + Architects transforms a modest cottage into a spacious family house while celebrating the area’s rich agricultural history and spectacular coastal views.

Stone Walls Crafting History and Function

Drawing inspiration from traditional livestock pens built from glacial rubble, substantial stone walls form the backbone of the new design. They rise through the home’s first floor, shaping the interior layout and supporting the upper level.

These walls also integrate into the sloping hillside, cleverly reducing the house’s perceived size from the outside. As they taper into the landscape, they create frames for views, illuminate interiors, link outdoor areas, and connect the architecture to the swimming pool.

To further explore the intersection of architecture and natural landscapes, Unique Metal and Wood Observational Tower offers an inspiring look at innovative design harmonizing with nature.

Stone walls inspired by livestock pens surround this Montauk home's architecture and views.
Historic livestock pens inspired the striking stone walls of this Montauk home, shaping the architecture while framing beautiful views across the landscape.

Clever Spaces Opening Up to Montauk’s Horizons

Stone walls at a Montauk home frame views, echoing historic livestock pens.
Historic livestock pens inspired the striking stone walls of this Montauk home, shaping the architecture while framing beautiful views across the landscape.

Nestled between two upper structures, an open-plan living room, dining area, and kitchen form the heart of the home. Large sliding glass walls vanish into hidden recesses, allowing the entire central area to open for uninterrupted vistas from sunrise to sunset.

Montauk home features stone architecture, inspired by historic livestock pens and stunning surroundings.
Historic livestock pens inspired the striking stone walls of this Montauk home, shaping the architecture while framing beautiful views across the landscape.

Inside, stone walls define spaces, complemented by freestanding cabinetry and built-in shelving that foster a smooth transition between rooms. A subtle shelving unit divides the living room and kitchen without disrupting the open feel.

For more creative architectural designs, discover how How To Shade Bay Windows can enhance your home’s comfort and aesthetic appeal.

Bright living area with sliding glass walls and natural stone, offering indoor-outdoor flow.
Sliding glass walls and natural stone create a bright, open living area where indoor and outdoor spaces flow together with panoramic water views.

Intimate Corners with Sweeping Views

Open living space in Montauk home with glass walls, panoramic views, and natural stone.
Sliding glass walls and natural stone create a bright, open living area where indoor and outdoor spaces flow together with panoramic water views.

Beyond the main living area, cozy spots enhance everyday comfort. A secondary dining nook, complete with built-in banquette seating, overlooks the pool, offering a serene escape. A separate living room invites relaxation with its tranquil water views. The stone walls’ texture and continuity extend outdoors, visually uniting the architecture with the pool.

Indoor space with sliding glass walls opening to outdoor panoramic views and stone finishes.
Sliding glass walls and natural stone create a bright, open living area where indoor and outdoor spaces flow together with panoramic water views.

Echoes of Tradition in Twin Cottages

Banquette seating in Montauk home with stone walls overlooking pool and water views.
Built-in banquette seating, a quiet lounge, and stone walls throughout the home create warm, inviting spaces with beautiful pool and water views.

Two shingled forms rest above a stone foundation, resembling the original cottages. With much of the first floor nestled into the hillside, these upper structures appear as modest homes gently perched on the landscape.

Warm Montauk home interior with lounge seating, stone walls, and poolside views.
Built-in banquette seating, a quiet lounge, and stone walls throughout the home create warm, inviting spaces with beautiful pool and water views.

Each cottage is accessible by its own staircase, and a spacious roof deck lies between them. Their positioning lets each bedroom revel in optimally captured vistas—whether of the lake, sound, ocean, or nature preserves.

Shingled cottages above stone base in Montauk home optimize bedroom views.
Two shingled cottage-inspired volumes sit above a hidden stone base, giving this Montauk home its distinctive appearance and maximizing every bedroom view.

Spacious Bedrooms with Vaulted Ceilings

Montauk home's cottage-style volumes on stone base maximize views from each bedroom.
Two shingled cottage-inspired volumes sit above a hidden stone base, giving this Montauk home its distinctive appearance and maximizing every bedroom view.

Inside, the bedrooms surprise with their vaulted ceilings. Custom wood headboards incorporate bedside tables and lighting into a streamlined design. Floor-to-ceiling windows dominate the rooms, transforming the surrounding scenery into dynamic, living art.

Bedroom with vaulted ceilings, wood accents, and large windows amidst natural surroundings.
Vaulted ceilings, custom wood details, and floor-to-ceiling windows make these bedrooms feel bright, spacious, and surrounded by nature.

Bathrooms Harmonizing with the Modern Design

Bright, spacious bedroom with wood details, vaulted ceilings, and nature views.
Vaulted ceilings, custom wood details, and floor-to-ceiling windows make these bedrooms feel bright, spacious, and surrounded by nature.

A bathroom continues the home’s restrained palette, featuring thick black-framed shower screens that mirror the home’s window frames. The bold, contrasting details emphasize the home’s architectural consistency.

Modern bathroom with black-framed shower screens and windows, complementing home design.
Black-framed shower screens and matching windows give this modern bathroom a clean, timeless look that complements the rest of the home.

This Montauk residence honors its historic site without mimicking the past. Leveraging traditional materials, iconic forms, and the dramatic hillside, the design nestles naturally into its environment. Expansive living spaces and family-friendly areas make it ideal for contemporary living.

Source: contemporist.com

Frequently asked questions

How does the Montauk home embrace the area’s history?

The Montauk home embraces the area’s history by nodding to the region’s agricultural past and incorporating remnants of horse stables and workers’ cottages from the landscape.

What is the layout and design of the main living area?

The main living area features an open-plan living room, dining area, and kitchen with large sliding glass walls that vanish into hidden recesses, offering uninterrupted vistas from sunrise to sunset.

How do the stone walls contribute to the home’s design?

The stone walls, inspired by traditional livestock pens, form the backbone of the new design, shaping the interior layout, supporting the upper level, and integrating into the sloping hillside to create frames for views and connect with outdoor areas.