Harvard student concept for the trump arch memorial circle, with a triumphal arch, water pools, and open sightlines.

Harvard Students Propose Water Pools and Open Sightlines Instead of Trump’s Arch

User avatar placeholder
Written by Seth Sebastian

2026-11-19

Two landscape architecture students at Harvard’s Graduate School of Design want Memorial Circle in Washington, DC, to look nothing like a triumphal arch. Their proposals for the trump arch memorial circle replace the traffic roundabout with broad pools of water and open long sightlines toward the Lincoln Memorial and Arlington Cemetery.

The students, Jeremy Dvorak and Jake Geitner, developed the designs with The Cultural Landscape Foundation, a Washington nonprofit that educates the public about landscape heritage. The pair says the federal government did not open the arch project to meaningful public review. Their designs are meant to fill that gap.

Proposed new road shown as an open plaza on days the bridge is closed.
The new road would turn into a plaza on days when the bridge is closed

Both schemes connect to the city’s historic processional axis, the historic route between Washington and Arlington, and both treat the trump arch memorial circle as a place to walk through rather than simply pass. Dvorak and Geitner describe their work as a counterpoint to the arch rather than a rejection of monumentality.

“By recognising Memorial Circle’s implicit expressions of monumentality, this pair of counter proposals asserts design’s capacity to critically engage history, accommodate public life, and advocate on behalf of our shared cultural landscape,” the designers said.

The project grew out of a seminar taught at the Graduate School of Design by Charles A Birnbaum, founding partner of The Cultural Landscape Foundation. Dvorak and Geitner said the course pushed them to root their practice in historical research and public participation.

Design sketches questioning the triumphal arch, presenting alternative ideas for the memorial circle site.
Triumphal Arch provocations

A quiet pool and a straight road

The first proposal treats the trump arch memorial circle as a gap in the historic axis between Washington and Arlington. The designers fill the central roundabout, now a lawn, with a low pool of water.

A natural stone edge rings the pool. The stone carries inscribed words about belonging and unity.

The team calls the design restrained. It is meant to be seen mainly from a car as drivers pass through the circle.

For another look at how a landscape carries heavy historical meaning, Sycamore Gap Tree’s Resilient Comeback on Hadrian’s Wall shows how a beloved landmark recovers after loss.

The second proposal removes the traffic circle altogether. A straight thoroughfare runs to Arlington Memorial Bridge, flanked by two circular fountains. A large pool that mirrors the footprint of the old circle would fill the site during commemorative events, when the bridge is closed to traffic.

The designers drew on earlier proposals for Memorial Circle to shape the geometry. “[The fountain] geometries arise from the site’s historic proposals, combining concentric circles, intersecting alignments, and formal planting into a composition that acknowledges history whilst creating its own present identity,” they said. “In this way the landscape becomes a physical record of its own change.”

The trump arch memorial circle and the legal fight

Trump’s proposed arch was announced last year, with renderings by the US studio Harrison Design. The neoclassical structure would feature gilded statues. Critics have nicknamed it the “Arc de Trump,” a play on the Arc de Triomphe in Paris, and see it as a modern trump triumphal arch built to celebrate the president.

Construction was set to start in September, but it was halted in early November by Judge Tanya S Chutkan. Trump has described the arch as a “military complex” with snipers, linking the project to national security.

Opposition centres on how the trump arch memorial circle project would affect views of Arlington Cemetery. Members of the Kennedy family, who filed a lawsuit to block construction, argue that the structure would cast shadows over the grave of President John F Kennedy.

Public monuments also invite fierce debate over who gets seen in them, as Tschabalala Self’s Lady in Blue at Trafalgar Square sparks its own dialogue about inclusion in a historic setting.

The US Commission of Fine Arts (CFA), which reviews projects in the capital, approved the arch in May.

The student proposals also arrive as Congress weighs changes to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act. That provision requires federal agencies to weigh the effects of their projects on historic properties. Protesters gathered in Washington in early November to oppose the administration’s proposed rewrite of these protections, which sit within the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA), a bill recently introduced in Congress.

The Harvard designs for the trump arch memorial circle make a simple argument. A memorial landscape can honour history by keeping the view open, and the public can use it every day.

Harvard student concept for the trump arch memorial circle, with a triumphal arch, water pools, and open sightlines.
Triumphal Arch

Via dezeen.com

Frequently asked questions

Who designed the Harvard proposals for Memorial Circle in Washington?

Landscape architecture students Jeremy Dvorak and Jake Geitner at Harvard’s Graduate School of Design developed the proposals with The Cultural Landscape Foundation. The project grew out of a seminar taught by Charles A Birnbaum, the foundation’s founding partner.

Why was construction of Trump’s arch at Memorial Circle halted?

Construction was halted in early November by Judge Tanya S Chutkan. The Kennedy family filed a lawsuit to block construction, arguing the structure would cast shadows over the grave of President John F Kennedy.

What does the first Harvard proposal do with Memorial Circle?

The first proposal fills the central roundabout, now a lawn, with a low pool of water ringed by a natural stone edge inscribed with words about belonging and unity. The designers intend it to be seen mainly from a car as drivers pass through the circle.

How does the second Harvard proposal change the traffic circle?

The second proposal removes the traffic circle and runs a straight thoroughfare to Arlington Memorial Bridge, flanked by two circular fountains. A large pool mirroring the old circle’s footprint would fill the site during commemorative events, when the bridge is closed to traffic.

Menu